Fayetteville’s tremendous food scene was one of the major reasons we created Lafayette Flat Boutique Vacation Rentals a decade ago this year. For a town of less than 3,000 people, the number of outstanding locally-owned eateries defies explanation, except that – like us – people who come to New River Gorge National Park to hike, bike, climb and paddle love good food. Here are our favorites.

Tuscan Chicken and Gnocchi at the Gaines Estate

The most upscale restaurant in Fayetteville is located in an historic mansion just a short walk from downtown. We recently had the Tuscan Chicken and Gnocchi (perfectly seasoned chicken, hand-made gnocchi, sundried tomatoes, spinach, and baby bella mushrooms in a white sauce). It was absolutely scrumptious and we can’t wait to have it again.

The Van Buren at Secret Sandwich Society

To say Secret Sandwich Society is a Fayetteville institution is woefully inadequate. When it suffered a catastrophic fire a few years ago, the heartache was felt through the whole community. Now it’s back and better than ever with its signature sandwiches and salads. The Van Buren is a classic pastrami on rye and one of our favorites – in a place where it’s hard to pick a favorite.

Sushi Bowl at the Takeout

As the name implies, this unique restaurant specializes in food to go, and Amy’s favorite is the Sushi Bowl (rice, salmon, tuna, crab, carrot, avocado, scallions, sweet soy glaze, sriracha, aioli, and crispy fried onions). They also have a menu of flavor combinations you can try in a salad or a sandwich. Stop by their new location on Court St. for some healthy, colorful, yummy food.

Heirloom Tomato Pie at Pies and Pints

The best pizza on the planet. Unfortunately, it is only available late summer to early fall when tomatoes are fresh and full of flavor. Thankfully, many of the other special artisan pizzas they offer keep us satisfied from October to August. In addition to being delicious, Pies and Pints is rock solid with their hours of operation which we greatly appreciate.

Carrot Cake at Cathedral Cafe

Legendary. That’s the word for Cathedral’s carrot cake. Located in an old church just a block away from Lafayette Flats, Cathedral Cafe’s ambience is pretty great too. They’ve been closed for the past couple of months but their remodel is complete, and they are once again churning out carrot cake and other great breakfast, lunch and drink specialties.

Any Tudor’s Biscuit

They’re huge, greasy, and unquestionably unhealthy—and every West Virginian adores them. Amy’s loyal to the Mary B, while Shawn swears by the Thundering Herd. We only indulge once in a while, but when we do, it’s pure bliss. Just take a hike or raft the river afterward and you can pretend it all balances out.

Birria Tacos at Tequila Taco Bar

We love Mexican cuisine, and Tequila Taco Bar – a relative newcomer to the Fayetteville restaurant lineup – is one of our favorite places to visit for the usual dishes as well as some unique offerings. Shawn is particularly fond of Birria Tacos. Not sure which taco is your favorite? Try Tequila Taco’s taco flight!

Belgian Waffle at Wood Iron Eatery

We love Wood Iron’s waffles, but who doesn’t? The maple drizzle is delish, but it’s the honeycomb butter that really takes it up a notch. They also serve one one of our favorite lunch sandwiches, the Rockfish. It is a twist on the classic fish sandwich with its brioche bun, greens, lemon tartar, and house made lemon vinaigrette.

Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich at Southside Junction Tap House

Southside is a lively spot to have a cold brew and they serve up some tasty eats too. Their specials are always on point, but our favorite menu item is the Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich (fried chicken in house-made Nashville Hot Sauce topped with slaw and pickles).

West Virginia Hotdogs at Swiftwater General Store

While not geographically eligible to be included in a list of Fayetteville foods, we think the short drive across the big bridge is worth the exception to get West Virginia-style hot dogs at Swiftwater General Store. What’s a WV-style hotdog? Chili, slaw, mustard and onion.

Craving more data for your New River Gorge exploration? Read “What Makes Little Fayetteville, WV so Special?” and “Our 10 Favorite Things About Fayetteville, WV.”